The Butcher knife and the cleaver have long been favorites of professional and amateur chefs alike. While the butcher knife is synonymous with the meat processing trade, hefty in stature and capable of cutting, stripping, and splitting meat, the cleaver offers similar capabilities, but with a more refined, lighter, and thinner blade, ideal for precise cuts.
Let’s dive right in and explain the differences between Butcher Knife and Cleaver.
Differences Between Cleaver and Butcher Knife
|Blade size (not including handle)||6-8”||6-14”|
|Ability to cut the bone||Moderate (good for smaller cuts & thinner bones. Offers a more delicate and precise cut)||High (ideal for dressing full carcasses and working in the meat trades/butcher)|
|Weight||*Corresponds to knife size*|
Can weigh up to 2.5 lbs
|*Corresponds to knife size*|
Can weight up to 2.5 lbs
Often around .2 centimeters thick
Often around 0.2-0.25 centimeters thick
What is a Butcher Knife?
This knife, unsurprisingly, is the go-to tool for your friendly neighborhood butcher and is used for trimming and dressing meat. Its heavy, curved blade is designed to make short work of any section of meat that might arrive on your cutting board. If you love a good roast, steak, or BBQ and you’ve got a few hungry mouths to feed, this is one weapon you definitely need in your arsenal. It’ll break down large pieces of meat with ease and slice off any unwanted fat or gristle for a leaner cut.
Butcher Knife Best Uses:
- Best for those who work in the meat trades.
- Best for butchers.
- Ideal for chefs who dress and prep their own raw meat.
- Great for thick, tough cuts, and in-bone cuts.
- Perfect for cleaving meat from the bone.
What is a Cleaver?
If horror movies haven’t put you completely off it, the cleaver is one of the most useful and versatile knives you can have in your kitchen. It’s also the biggest, a proper heavyweight. With a thick, soft steel blade it’s designed to chop right through thick pieces of meat, cartilage, and bone without losing its edge. The heavy side of the knife can be used for tenderizing the flesh or even crushing garlic if you fancy a little more delicate work after rending your dinner limb from limb.
Cleaver Best Uses:
- Ideal for the carnivorous chef
- Perfect companion for preparing most meats
- Offers more precision and a cleaner, gentler cut
- Not ideal for a full carcass of meat
Butcher Knife Vs Cleaver: Which One Should You Use?
If you’re a meat lover, you’re going to want both these bad boys in your kitchen. But, if you are having to make the truly heart-breaking choice to pick one implement to slice, dice, and chop your dinner, this should give you some pointers on whether you should go for a butcher knife or a cleaver.
Both of these tools use thicker blades than your other kitchen knives. They’re heavy-duty pieces of kit, designed to tackle the pieces of meat and fat that other, flimsier blades would struggle to cut. Both come in a range of sizes, so you can pick one to suit you. It’ll depend on how you want the knife to feel in your hand and what you’re wanting to do with it.
- Most butcher knives come in a range of 6 to 14 inches and the smaller the knife, the smaller the piece of meat you’ll want to be working on. These are great for chops or fillets and can get around bone really well. If you’ve got a bigger hunk of flesh to take care of, go for a bigger knife. They’re perfect for skinning and, if you know your meat, you can use them to break down your animal into as many juicy steaks as you can handle. Your typical home chef tends to have one in the middle, around 8 to 10 inches, but you know better than anyone what you want to do with it, so you can buy accordingly.
- Your cleaver should be built to give and take a serious pounding. With a classic rectangular shape and thick blade, they also come in a range of sizes, typically between 6 and 8 inches. This is helpful because everyone’s arms are also different lengths and when you’re using this tool, you want it to feel comfortable in your hand and not go flying off into the wall. You’re also looking for a balanced but tough blade that will cut through meat, sinew, and bone again and again. It doesn’t need to be razor-sharp, as blunt force is your main weapon here but it should be keen enough to slice through without tearing the food.
Bone Cutting Ability
No bones about it (sorry), both the butcher knife and the cleaver can tackle your animal’s skeleton, but only one is specifically designed for the task. Butcher knives with less flexible blades will be able to break through small bones, like those in poultry, but for anything larger, that’s where your sturdy cleaver comes into its own. If you are looking for a good quality boning knife, we have a buying guide here.
- Your butcher knife is a wonderful tool but is more useful for separating flesh from bones than smashing through them. If you have a less flexible butcher’s blade you should be able to chop through small bones without much fuss but it’s not your butcher knife’s primary job. If you have a curved blade it will help you get around the bones much more easily.
- This is where the one-punch KO (knockout) power of your heavyweight cleaver comes into its own. If you’ve got a heavy-duty, sturdy cleaver with a soft-steel blunt edge and you can control it comfortably, those bones stand no chance. You’ll bust straight through them. The amount of force required to do this though means you should make sure your cleaver is a great fit for your hand.
Weight of the Knife
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, these are the heavyweights of your kitchen cutting tools, although there is a fair weight difference between the two. Think of your butcher’s knife as Mike Tyson and your cleaver as George Foreman. Both very big lads, but one a fair bit bigger than the other.
- As butcher knives come in a range of sizes, the weight will also vary. A butcher knife with an 8-inch blade is likely to weigh just over 3 ounces. You know yourself what you’re most likely to be cooking for dinner, so you can pick accordingly. A larger, heavier butcher knife will take on heavy-duty pieces of meat with ease, whereas a smaller one will slice you beautiful steaks or a cut for your roast.
- The weight of your cleaver will correspond to its blade length and height. The more of that you have the heavier your cleaver is likely to be. Some behemoths can weigh up to 2.5 pounds with an 8-inch blade. Unsurprisingly, using one of these requires a fair bit of strength, and if you’re not planning to be chopping through whole cows regularly you can find much lighter versions that’ll do the business. Plenty weigh around 1 pound and should give you all the punch you need.
Thickness of the Blade
Again, heavy tool = thicker blade. A quality butcher knife and cleaver are designed to take on the largest cuts of meat with ease while still keeping its edge. Both will probably have the thickest blades of any other cutting tool in your kitchen.
- Butcher knives have slightly thicker blades than other knives as they’re designed to cut through and separate large pieces of meat from the bone. Anything over 1/8 of an inch is probably overkill though. Today’s high-quality stainless-steel means that blades remain sharper for longer and can take more punishment. So, all things being equal, if you’ve got a good steel blade you can go for one that’s slightly thinner which will slice more efficiently.
- Your cleaver’s blade is THICK – from its cutting edge to its spine. A Western cleaver can range from a relatively slim 13 degrees to a wide 25 degrees. You’ll want to look out for a solid, chunky spine that’ll give you the solidity to chop through bones with less effort and won’t warp on impact. Something that measures between 0.25 and 0.75 inches should be ideal but again, it’s best to pick something that just feels right for your hand. You want to be in full control of it at all times.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should a meat cleaver be sharp?
Because your cleaver is going to be using a great deal of blunt force, it doesn’t need to be razor-sharp. If it’s too thin it’ll end up folding and spoiling your chopping.
What knife can cut through bone?
Both a cleaver and a butcher knife can cut through bone but your cleaver should be your go-to skeleton smasher.
Why does a butcher’s knife have that hole?
The hole helps to avoid a vacuum forming when the blade is cutting something, meaning you can pull it out more easily.
What is a good meat cleaver?
A good cleaver is sturdy, heavy-duty, and made of quality stainless steel. But it’s a personal thing also. A cleaver really needs to feel comfortable in the user’s hand.
Why is the cleaver so popular in Chinese cooking?
A Chinese cleaver has a much slimmer blade than the Western cleaver and is really more of a knife than a hatchet. It’s very versatile and great for slicing, dicing, and chopping but don’t use it to cut those bones!
What’s the best way to store a meat cleaver?
If it’s got a hole in the end you can hang it up for easy access for you in your kitchen. If not, make sure it’s somewhere secure where any curious little hands can’t get to it.
Or you can use this magnetic storage strip for any large and heavy cleaver.
What Does a Butcher Knife Look Like?
A butcher’s knife is one of the largest kitchen knives, often with a curved blade.
What is a cleaver knife used for?
Cutting large chunks of meat, sinew, and bone.
What is a butcher knife used for?
Mainly separating large chunks of meat from the bone and trimming them into steaks or restaurant-sized portions.
So Which One is Better, the Butcher or the Cleaver?
Phew! What a slugfest, eh? The great thing about these two kitchen titans is that 12 rounds are nothing for them. They should still be going strong 12 years from now.
Turns out, which knife is better depends on how you plan to use it, what you frequently cook, and whether or not you can afford to buy both.
If you’re a serious carnivore then both of them are essential additions to your culinary arsenal. The butcher knife will slice you steaks to die for while your cleaver will make quick work of the toughest cuts and bone-in pieces that come out of your freezer. And if you can only have one? Hey, that’s up to you. I’m not saying no to either of these guys. Especially not to their faces.